Final · Nov 17Tue, Nov 17 · 7:08 PM ET

Islanders vs Blue JacketsFinal Score & Recap

Islanders

10-6
5–1

Blue Jackets

8-12

21+ · Bet responsibly

How the picks graded

Expert picks
5-0
100% on this game
Our pick
Won
Islanders ML (-143)

Amedeus Mastrangelo won on this game

Now 7-5 on NHL picks over the last 30 days

Profile

Next up for the Islanders

Detroit Red Wings vs New York Islanders

Sat, Nov 21 · 7:00 PM ET

Get the next game's picks

Every result above is graded in public: wins and losses

Expert picks for this game

5 verified handicappers picked Islanders vs Blue Jackets. Every graded pick is shown with its result. Records are NHL, last 30 days.

  • Amedeus Mastrangelo

    7-6 · 53.8%

    +$71
    Record
    Win %
    Profit
    MoneylineNEW YORK ISLANDERS ML -143Won
  • Wise Guy Plays

    7-7 · 50.0%

    -$178
    Record
    Win %
    Profit
    MoneylineNEW YORK ISLANDERS ML -141Won
  • Pro Picks - Andrew

    20-23 · 46.5%

    -$681
    Record
    Win %
    Profit
    MoneylineNEW YORK ISLANDERS ML -141Won
  • GA Algorithm

    36-48 · 42.9%

    -$1,412
    Record
    Win %
    Profit
    Puck lineNEW YORK ISLANDERS -1.5 +190Won
  • Knup Sports - POTD

    68-93 · 42.2%

    -$3,626
    Record
    Win %
    Profit
    MoneylineNEW YORK ISLANDERS ML -141Won

Where the experts landed

How many of the 5 handicappers on this game picked each market, and whether the best of them agree.

All experts

4 of 5 picked the moneyline

Top 25% NHL experts

Fewer than 3 top-quartile experts picked this market.

Small samples are noisy: consensus is a signal, not a pick.

Recap · Tue, Nov 17

Islanders vs Blue Jackets Recap: Final Score & Pick Result (Nov 17, 2026)

By SportsHub Model · Edited by Kyle Parker

Final · · Recap updated

Islanders vs Blue Jackets recap card for Nov. 17, 2026: Islanders 5, Blue Jackets 1, Islanders moneyline at -143 won, shots 41-29

Final: November 17, 2026 | Recap updated: November 17, 2026, 10:35 PM ET

The New York Islanders beat the Columbus Blue Jackets 5-1 on Tuesday night at UBS Arena. Rookie defenseman Matthew Schaefer scored a hat trick, including two goals in the third period, and Ilya Sorokin made 28 saves. Our pick, Islanders moneyline (-143), won. New York has won three straight, while Columbus has lost five in a row.

Islanders vs Blue Jackets Final Score

Team1st2nd3rdFinal
New York Islanders1135
Columbus Blue Jackets0011

Decided in regulation. Shots on goal: New York 41, Columbus 29. Power plays: New York 1-for-2, Columbus 0-for-0.

How It Happened

The Islanders struck on their first power play. With Columbus serving a slashing minor, Anthony Duclair finished a feed from Mathew Barzal at 19:02 of the first period, with Tony DeAngelo also assisting, for a 1-0 lead.

Schaefer made it 2-0 just 1:34 into the second with an unassisted wrist shot.

The Blue Jackets finally answered 1:12 into the third. Zach Werenski scored off passes from Kent Johnson and Luca Del Bel Belluz to cut it to 2-1. The turning point came at 7:01: Schaefer restored the two-goal lead on a backhand from Ryan Pulock and Duclair, and Columbus took a delay-of-game minor for an unsuccessful challenge on the play.

DeAngelo added a backhand at 11:52, set up by Barzal and Matias Maccelli, for a 4-1 lead. Schaefer completed the hat trick with an empty-net goal at 16:08, assisted by Simon Holmstrom and Bo Horvat.

Top Performers

PlayerTeamLine
Matthew SchaeferNYI3 goals (1 empty-net), 9 shots, 23:23 TOI
Ilya SorokinNYI28 saves on 29 shots (.966)
Anthony DuclairNYI1 goal (power play), 1 assist
Tony DeAngeloNYI1 goal, 1 assist
Cam TalbotCBJ36 saves on 40 shots (.900)

Our Pick: Won

Our pick was the Islanders moneyline at -143. New York won 5-1, so the pick won, returning +$69.93 per $100 (100 × 100 / 143).

How the preview's reasons held up:

  • Model vs. market (held): the model had New York at 68%, above the 58-60% implied by the -139 to -147 prices. The Islanders won by four.
  • Columbus is cold (held): the Blue Jackets arrived on a four-game skid, outscored 16-7. They've now lost five straight by a combined 21-8 and are 1-6 on the road.
  • Special teams (held): New York's power play scored the opening goal, and Columbus never got a power play to test the Islanders' 85.9% penalty kill.
  • Goaltending (tilted to New York): the preview rated Sorokin's .915 ahead of Talbot's .909, and flagged Talbot's .930 run as the main risk. Sorokin stopped 28 of 29 (.966); Talbot stopped 36 of 40 (.900).
  • Shot volume (didn't hurt): the preview noted New York gets outshot, 29.1 shots against to 25.5 for. This time the Islanders outshot Columbus 41-29.

Betting Results

  • Moneyline: New York won at -139 to -147; Columbus was +119 to +123.
  • Puck line: the Islanders won by four, so they covered -1.5.
  • Total: 6 goals, over the 5.5 posted before the game. The preview passed on the total, and the sixth goal was the empty-netter.

SportsHub Handicappers: Last Week

Three of the leaders on the NHL board for November 10–16:

HandicapperRecordNet ($)ROI
Sports Central4-0+$40085.1%
Frankie the Fan13-8+$2678.4%
Neal Harris2-0+$20066.7%

See every record on the handicappers page.

What's Next

  • New York (10-6-4, 24 points, fourth in the Metropolitan): visits Winnipeg on Thursday, Nov. 19 at 7:00 PM ET (MSGSN, TSN3) in Jets vs Islanders, then plays at Detroit on Saturday, Nov. 21 at 7:00 PM ET in Red Wings vs Islanders.
  • Columbus (7-12-0, 14 points, last in the Metropolitan): continues its road trip at Chicago on Thursday, Nov. 19 at 8:00 PM ET (CBJHN, CHSN) in Blackhawks vs Blue Jackets, then visits Toronto on Saturday, Nov. 21 at 7:00 PM ET in Blue Jackets vs Maple Leafs.
  • The teams meet again on Feb. 22 in Columbus.

More: NHL picks · NHL news · Handicappers

Get expert NHL picks every day

Every pick from every SportsHub expert, graded in public.

Pregame preview

Islanders vs Blue Jackets Prediction, Picks & Odds (Nov. 17, 2026)

By SportsHub Model · Edited by Kyle Parker

The 20-second version

  • Our pick: Islanders moneyline at -143. The model gives New York 68%, above the 58-60% the licensed prices imply.
  • Columbus has lost four straight, been outscored 16-7 in that run and is 1-5 on the road.
  • New York's 85.9% penalty kill meets an 18.2% Columbus power play, and the Blue Jackets kill only 73.5%.
  • Starters set: Ilya Sorokin (.915) vs Cam Talbot (.909, .930 over his last seven), not Jet Greaves (.875).

The New York Islanders (9-6-4) host the Columbus Blue Jackets (7-11-0) at UBS Arena on Tuesday, Nov. 17 at 7:00 p.m. ET (MSGSN, ESPN+). Licensed books have New York between -139 and -147 on the moneyline, with the total at 5.5. Ilya Sorokin starts against Cam Talbot. Columbus has lost four straight and scored seven goals in that run. Our pick: Islanders moneyline (-143).

How these teams got here

New York's trip started badly and ended well. A 3-2 shootout loss in San Jose on Nov. 9 capped an 0-2-2 stretch. Then the Islanders went 5-2 in Los Angeles and 6-2 in Anaheim, scoring 11 goals in two nights. Mathew Barzal was activated from his knee injury and made his season debut Saturday, playing 16:21. The Islanders sit fourth in the Metropolitan with 22 points, scoring 3.11 goals per game and allowing 2.84. Tuesday is their first home game since Nov. 7, on two days' rest after the flight back from the West Coast.

Columbus is going the other way. The Blue Jackets lost 5-2 in Buffalo, 4-1 to Florida, 3-1 to Tampa Bay and 4-3 to Philadelphia, so they've been outscored 16-7 over the four-game skid. They're last in the Metropolitan with 14 points, average 2.39 goals for and 3.22 against, and have only two regulation wins all season. Tuesday opens a four-game road trip (Islanders, Chicago, Toronto, New Jersey) for a team that is 1-5 away from Nationwide Arena.

Special teams and the crease

Special teams are the biggest gap. New York kills 85.9% of its penalties, while Columbus converts 18.2% of its power plays. At the other end, the Blue Jackets kill only 73.5%, so an Islanders power play at 17.2% should get chances. Bo Horvat leads New York with five power-play goals among his nine. Simon Holmstrom also has nine goals, and rookie defenseman Matthew Schaefer leads the team with 21 points after logging 25:47 on Saturday.

Columbus runs through Kent Johnson (8 goals, 18 points), Zach Werenski (15 points) and Charlie Coyle (13). Johnson is the threat to watch, but the Jackets have scored more than two goals only once in their last four.

Both starters are set. Ilya Sorokin gets the net for New York. He started two of the three California games, stopping 39 of 41 in San Jose and 26 of 28 in Los Angeles, and he's at .915 with a 2.53 GAA. Columbus goes with Cam Talbot (5-3, .909) rather than Jet Greaves (.875, 3.42), who had started the last two. That narrows the goalie gap: Talbot has a 1.98 GAA and .930 save percentage over his last seven appearances, per Daily Faceoff. Sorokin still has the better season, but the crease is no longer a mismatch.

Injuries and lineup news

Columbus is thinner down the middle. Sean Monahan (upper body) is out and did not travel on the trip, per Daily Faceoff. Conor Garland is on injured reserve with an upper-body injury, retroactive to Nov. 6. The Jackets have already been playing without both, which helps explain the drop to seven goals in four games. They'll also be without head coach Rick Bowness, who is undergoing medical testing, per the Islanders' game-day preview.

New York has two lineup questions. Jean-Gabriel Pageau (lower body) has missed two games and is a game-time decision, per coach Pete DeBoer, after practicing Monday and taking part in Tuesday's optional skate. Logan Stanley (lower body) did not practice Monday or skate Tuesday and is not expected to play, with Matthew Kessel projected to step in. Alexander Romanov (knee) and Calum Ritchie remain on injured reserve, and DeBoer said Ritchie won't play Tuesday. Even without Stanley, Schaefer, Ryan Pulock, Adam Pelech and Tony DeAngelo all played 19-plus minutes on Saturday.

How the line has moved

The Islanders opened around -125 and have been bet to -139 to -147, with Columbus drifting from +105 to +119 to +123. The total has held at 5.5, with the over priced from -118 to -127. The market has moved toward New York, but not as far as the model.

Prediction: Islanders moneyline (-143)

We're on the Islanders moneyline at -143. The reasons:

  1. The model gives New York 68%, and the licensed prices imply 58-60%. That's a fair price near -213, so -143 still leaves room.
  2. Columbus is cold: four straight losses, outscored 16-7, 1-5 on the road and only two regulation wins in 18 games.
  3. Special teams favor New York: an 85.9% penalty kill against an 18.2% power play, and a 73.5% Columbus kill on the other side.
  4. Columbus is short at center, with Monahan out and Garland on IR, and it plays without its head coach behind the bench.
  5. The crease still leans New York, but less than it did: Sorokin's .915 against Talbot's .909.

The risk: Talbot's hot run. The Islanders get outshot, 29.1 shots against to 25.5 for per game, and they're 4-3-2 at home, so a goalie on a .930 stretch can steal a game like this.

The total: we pass on 5.5. Columbus scoring 2.39 a game pulls it under, and New York's 11 goals in two nights pull it over. The juiced over prices already reflect that.

Tale of the tape

Season to date. The better side of each stat is highlighted; league rank in brackets.

IslandersBlue Jackets
  • 3.2 Goals / game 2.5
  • 2.9 Goals against / game 3.3

Islanders vs Blue Jackets FAQ

Who won Islanders vs Blue Jackets on Nov 17, 2026?

The New York Islanders beat the Columbus Blue Jackets 5-1 at UBS Arena. Matthew Schaefer scored a hat trick and Ilya Sorokin made 28 saves.

What was the final score of Islanders vs Blue Jackets?

Islanders 5, Blue Jackets 1, in regulation. New York led 2-0 after two periods and scored three times in the third after Columbus cut it to 2-1.

Did the Islanders moneyline pick win?

Yes. Our pick was the Islanders moneyline at -143, and New York won 5-1, a return of $69.93 on a $100 stake.

Who was the top performer in Islanders vs Blue Jackets?

Rookie defenseman Matthew Schaefer scored three goals on nine shots, the last into an empty net, and Ilya Sorokin stopped 28 of 29 shots.

When do the Islanders and Blue Jackets play next?

The Islanders visit Winnipeg on Thursday, Nov. 19 at 7:00 PM ET. The Blue Jackets play at Chicago the same night at 8:00 PM ET. The teams meet again on Feb. 22 in Columbus.

Why bettors trust SportsHub

Picks you can verify, not promises.

Every expert's record is built from picks we timestamp before the game and grade after it. Wins and losses, in public.

  • 78+

    verified experts across every sport

  • Locked

    before the game starts: no edits

  • Graded

    in public, every pick, every day

Get free NHL picks in your inbox

Create a free account for free expert picks and our daily email. Unsubscribe anytime.