Recap · Tue, Nov 17
Islanders vs Blue Jackets Recap: Final Score & Pick Result (Nov 17, 2026)
By SportsHub Model · Edited by Kyle Parker
Final · · Recap updated

Final: November 17, 2026 | Recap updated: November 17, 2026, 10:35 PM ET
The New York Islanders beat the Columbus Blue Jackets 5-1 on Tuesday night at UBS Arena. Rookie defenseman Matthew Schaefer scored a hat trick, including two goals in the third period, and Ilya Sorokin made 28 saves. Our pick, Islanders moneyline (-143), won. New York has won three straight, while Columbus has lost five in a row.
Islanders vs Blue Jackets Final Score
| Team | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | Final |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| New York Islanders | 1 | 1 | 3 | 5 |
| Columbus Blue Jackets | 0 | 0 | 1 | 1 |
Decided in regulation. Shots on goal: New York 41, Columbus 29. Power plays: New York 1-for-2, Columbus 0-for-0.
How It Happened
The Islanders struck on their first power play. With Columbus serving a slashing minor, Anthony Duclair finished a feed from Mathew Barzal at 19:02 of the first period, with Tony DeAngelo also assisting, for a 1-0 lead.
Schaefer made it 2-0 just 1:34 into the second with an unassisted wrist shot.
The Blue Jackets finally answered 1:12 into the third. Zach Werenski scored off passes from Kent Johnson and Luca Del Bel Belluz to cut it to 2-1. The turning point came at 7:01: Schaefer restored the two-goal lead on a backhand from Ryan Pulock and Duclair, and Columbus took a delay-of-game minor for an unsuccessful challenge on the play.
DeAngelo added a backhand at 11:52, set up by Barzal and Matias Maccelli, for a 4-1 lead. Schaefer completed the hat trick with an empty-net goal at 16:08, assisted by Simon Holmstrom and Bo Horvat.
Top Performers
| Player | Team | Line |
|---|---|---|
| Matthew Schaefer | NYI | 3 goals (1 empty-net), 9 shots, 23:23 TOI |
| Ilya Sorokin | NYI | 28 saves on 29 shots (.966) |
| Anthony Duclair | NYI | 1 goal (power play), 1 assist |
| Tony DeAngelo | NYI | 1 goal, 1 assist |
| Cam Talbot | CBJ | 36 saves on 40 shots (.900) |
Our Pick: Won
Our pick was the Islanders moneyline at -143. New York won 5-1, so the pick won, returning +$69.93 per $100 (100 × 100 / 143).
How the preview's reasons held up:
- Model vs. market (held): the model had New York at 68%, above the 58-60% implied by the -139 to -147 prices. The Islanders won by four.
- Columbus is cold (held): the Blue Jackets arrived on a four-game skid, outscored 16-7. They've now lost five straight by a combined 21-8 and are 1-6 on the road.
- Special teams (held): New York's power play scored the opening goal, and Columbus never got a power play to test the Islanders' 85.9% penalty kill.
- Goaltending (tilted to New York): the preview rated Sorokin's .915 ahead of Talbot's .909, and flagged Talbot's .930 run as the main risk. Sorokin stopped 28 of 29 (.966); Talbot stopped 36 of 40 (.900).
- Shot volume (didn't hurt): the preview noted New York gets outshot, 29.1 shots against to 25.5 for. This time the Islanders outshot Columbus 41-29.
Betting Results
- Moneyline: New York won at -139 to -147; Columbus was +119 to +123.
- Puck line: the Islanders won by four, so they covered -1.5.
- Total: 6 goals, over the 5.5 posted before the game. The preview passed on the total, and the sixth goal was the empty-netter.
SportsHub Handicappers: Last Week
Three of the leaders on the NHL board for November 10–16:
| Handicapper | Record | Net ($) | ROI |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sports Central | 4-0 | +$400 | 85.1% |
| Frankie the Fan | 13-8 | +$267 | 8.4% |
| Neal Harris | 2-0 | +$200 | 66.7% |
See every record on the handicappers page.
What's Next
- New York (10-6-4, 24 points, fourth in the Metropolitan): visits Winnipeg on Thursday, Nov. 19 at 7:00 PM ET (MSGSN, TSN3) in Jets vs Islanders, then plays at Detroit on Saturday, Nov. 21 at 7:00 PM ET in Red Wings vs Islanders.
- Columbus (7-12-0, 14 points, last in the Metropolitan): continues its road trip at Chicago on Thursday, Nov. 19 at 8:00 PM ET (CBJHN, CHSN) in Blackhawks vs Blue Jackets, then visits Toronto on Saturday, Nov. 21 at 7:00 PM ET in Blue Jackets vs Maple Leafs.
- The teams meet again on Feb. 22 in Columbus.
More: NHL picks · NHL news · Handicappers
Get expert NHL picks every day
Every pick from every SportsHub expert, graded in public.









