Analysis
Inter Miami vs New York Red Bulls Prediction, Picks & Odds (Oct 24, 2026)
By SportsHub Model · Edited by Kyle Parker
The 20-second version
- No edge: the model likes Miami at 70%, but its 7% draw price is far below the books' 21-24%, so we pass on the 3-way line.
- Miami lead MLS with 73 goals (2.43 per game), and Messi has 25 goals and 15 assists.
- The Red Bulls are 9th in the East on 36 points, level with Toronto, and have lost three of their last four.
- Miami matches average 4.13 total goals, and the over 3.5 is priced at -161 to -167.

Inter Miami (15-10-5, 2nd in the East) visit the New York Red Bulls (10-6-14, 9th) on Saturday, Oct. 24 at 5:30 p.m. ET at Sports Illustrated Stadium in Harrison, N.J., live on Apple TV. Miami are -118 to -135 on the three-way moneyline, with the Red Bulls +235 to +260 and the draw +320 to +385. The league's highest-scoring attack meets a home side clinging to the last playoff spot. SportsHub's call: no edge.
How these teams got here
Miami arrive on a three-match winning streak: 4-0 over D.C. United, 2-0 over NYCFC and 3-1 at Atlanta last weekend. That run follows a 2-1 loss at Columbus and a 2-2 draw with San Diego, so this team still leaks. Their 73 goals (2.43 per game) lead MLS, but their 51 conceded (1.70 per game) sit closer to a mid-table side than a contender.
The Red Bulls are going the other way. They have lost three of their last four, including a 0-2 home loss to Toronto last time out and a 0-3 home defeat to St. Louis City before that. They have scored 39 goals (1.30 per game) and allowed 56 (1.87), a -17 goal difference. They sit ninth on 36 points, level with tenth-placed Toronto and only ahead on wins, with four regular-season games left (per Sports Mole). The top nine make the playoffs, so this is a home game they need far more than Miami do.
Messi against a defense that bends
Everything starts with Lionel Messi. He scored twice and set up another goal in Atlanta, which took him to 25 goals and 15 assists, first in MLS in goals and tied for first in assists (per TSN's match report). Germán Berterame has nine goals, and Luis Suárez has a career-high 11 assists. Those three all had a hand in at least two of the three goals in Atlanta.
The Red Bulls' best hope going forward is Julian Hall, who has 11 goals this season (per FotMob). The problem is the support around him. New York have been shut out in two of their last four, and 39 goals is the lowest total among teams currently in a playoff position (per Sports Mole).
The matchup that decides it is Miami's front three against a back line that has given up 1.87 goals per game. Miami have scored three or more in six away league games this year (per Sports Mole). The catch is at the other end: before this winning streak, Miami conceded two goals in three straight matches (Nashville, San Diego, Columbus), so New York don't need many chances to stay in it.
Who's missing
Miami travel without attackers Tadeo Allende and Mateo Silvetti, both out. Teenage midfielder Fricio Caicedo is questionable with a lower-body issue. Allende's absence thins the attacking depth behind Messi, Suárez and Berterame, though Miami have scored nine goals in three games without him.
For New York, defender Devin Padelford (concussion) and midfielder Ronald Donkor (leg) are both questionable. Both are projected starters if fit. Sports Mole reports that goalkeeper AJ Marcucci is out with a cruciate ligament tear and that Ethan Horvath will start, though not every outlet lists Marcucci, so check the lineups an hour before kickoff.
What the market is saying
Miami's price is tight across the licensed books (-118 to -135), and the draw sits at +320 to +385. The total is 3.5, with the over a steep -161 to -167 at the books that offer it, so the market expects goals. That fits these numbers: Miami's matches average 4.13 total goals, and the Red Bulls' average 3.17.
Prediction: no edge
Our model makes Miami a 70% winner, well above the roughly 51-54% the market implies once the vig is removed. We aren't headlining it. That same model gives the draw only 7%, about a third of the 21-24% the books price it at. When the draw is that badly mispriced, the 70% isn't reliable enough to bet into.
- Miami's attack is real: 2.43 goals per game, with Messi at 25 goals and 15 assists.
- So is their defensive problem: they allow 1.70 goals per game.
- New York have more to play for: they sit ninth on 36 points, level with tenth-placed Toronto.
- A short price on the road: -118 to -135 for an away win leaves little room if this ends in a draw.
The swing factor: whether Padelford and Donkor are fit. With both projected starters out, a Red Bulls side that has already conceded 56 goals has even less margin against Messi.
On the total: the over at 3.5 is priced at -161 or worse. That's fair for Miami's 4.13 goals per game but no bargain. We'd pass there too.




